There are several distinctions that students of the noble Quran may observe between Meccan and Medinan surahs. These differences can be explained through a number of key aspects, as outlined below:
First: The Difference Between Meccan and Medinan Surahs in Terms of Place of Revelation
Meccan Surahs
- These are the surahs that were revealed in Makkah Al-Mukarramah.
- This category also includes all surahs revealed before the Hijrah, even if their revelation occurred outside Makkah.
Medinan Surahs
- These are the surahs that were revealed in Madinah Al-Munawwarah.
- This category also includes all surahs revealed after the Hijrah, even if their revelation occurred outside Madinah.
Second: The Difference in Terms of the Length of Verses
- Meccan verses are generally characterised by brevity and conciseness.
- Medinan verses, on the other hand, are characterised by length and elaboration.
Reason for This Difference
- Meccan surahs addressed the most eloquent and articulate of the Arabs – the Quraysh of Makkah – and conciseness is a hallmark of eloquence.
- Medinan surahs often addressed and debated the Jews, refuting their false claims; they were not as linguistically eloquent as the native Arabs, which necessitated elaboration and clarification.
Third: The Difference in Terms of Subject Matter
Themes of Meccan Surahs
Meccan surahs address a wide range of themes, including:
- Matters of creed, such as the foundations of faith, affirmation of monotheism, prophethood, resurrection and the hereafter.
- Stories of the noble messengers (peace be upon them) and their nations.
They also established principles of morality and general ethical conduct, and refuted the arguments of polytheists.
If a surah contains the story of Adam and Iblīs, it is Meccan, with the exception of Surah al-Baqarah.
Themes of Medinan Surahs
Medinan surahs address a wide range of themes, including:
- Detailed legislative rulings and legal injunctions.
- Responses to the arguments of the People of the Book (Jews and Christians).
- Exposing attitudes and schemes of hypocrites.
- Discussions on jihād, including its permission, regulations and the treaties resulting from it.
Fourth: The Difference in Terms of the Number of Surahs
Medinan Surahs agreed upon by scholars
There are 20 surahs, namely:
- Al-Baqarah
- Āl ʿImrān
- An-Nisāʾ
- Al-Māʾidah
- Al-Anfāl
- At-Tawbah
- An-Nūr
- Al-Aḥzāb
- Muḥammad
- Al-Fatḥ
- Al-Ḥujurāt
- Al-Ḥadīd
- Al-Mujādilah
- Al-Ḥashr
- Al-Mumtaḥanah
- Al-Jumuʿah
- Al-Munāfiqūn
- Aṭ-Ṭalāq
- At-Taḥrīm
- An-Naṣr
Surahs Over Which Scholars Differ
They are 12 surahs, namely:
- Al-Fātiḥah
- Ar-Raʿd
- Ar-Raḥmān
- Aṣ-Ṣaff
- At-Taghābun
- Al-Muṭaffifīn
- Al-Qadr
- Al-Bayyinah
- Az-Zalzalah
- Al-Ikhlāṣ
- Al-Falaq
- An-Nās
Meccan Surahs Agreed Upon by Scholars
- They are 82 surahs, comprising the remaining surahs of the noble Quran.
Other Distinguishing Features
Forms of Address
Meccan surahs commonly use the form of address:
- (O mankind)
- They do not include: (O you who believe), as they address humanity at large.
- The address (O children of Adam) is also included among them.
Medinan surahs use the following forms of address:
- (O you who believe) when addressing the believers.
- (O Children of Israel) when addressing the Jews.
- (O People of the Book) when addressing Jews and Christians.
- The address (O mankind) may also appear, as it includes the believers as well.